Its pants!
It has a lot of gameplay issues (bad design desitions really), but thease can all be solved by modders, the real problem with it is the technical difficulties, namely that it loves crashing to the desktop any chance it gets, and i doubt any modders can fix that.
With the right patches and mods, it may still become a worthy successor to SoC, but it's not there yet..
And no, i haven't voted for it, or anything else really, i haven't played about half the games on that list because of the damned DRM.
I'm not sure what i'd vote for, 2008 was hardly a good year for PC gaming.