I haven't reached Level 5 on Support Specialist as yet, so the personal experience of simultaneously having both the AA12 and the Hunting Shotgun isn't something I can comment on. (I'm currently at 4.) In any case, for me, the non-expendable member of our trio of shotguns would be the HS. This weapon has the potential of pulling victory, (however fleeting), from the jaws of defeat more than the AA12, at least in my experience. And, make no mistake, I
really like the AA12.
The HS can deliver that much-needed "see 'ya!" dynamic to a marauding scrake or fleshpound, after a bit of abuse being delivered by others. (The Sharpie can't be everywhere, after all...) No, it isn't ideal for this application, and big-game hunting doesn't supersede keeping doors welded in certain maps. But, from what I've experienced thus far, it goes a long way towards leveling the odds against the heavyweights, and I like the feeling of confidence that having it brings. Which brings up another aspect of this discussion; the cost of the AA12 versus the HS.
If, as a Support-type you opt for the pump shotgun ASAP, the HS will be available, price-wise, long before the AA12. Yes, the HS ammunition is horribly expensive, but if used only in those "special moments," (you know the ones I mean
), the cost is manageable. Especially if you're lucky enough to come across the odd ammo box here and there. This assumes the handgun/pump shotgun combo is also being actively employed.
I'd say that you're likely to completely exhaust the AA12 ammo during a large wave, even on semi-auto and using good fire discipline. If you've sold your pump
and your HS to get your mitts on the AA12, you could then have an embarrassing moment. While the HS ammo loadout is just roughly half of the AA12, I think it often yields more dead zeds overall. I also like the flashlight option on the pump, and I would be reluctant to part with it. I've had good success simply illuminating dim targets for the benefit of Sharpies and others, firing only if necessary. Yeah, the 9mm can accomplish this, but then, you're just holding a handgun vs. holding a 12 gauge. Either way, it's something that must be used with discretion, because you don't want
everyone's eyes drawn to the same zed.
I do prefer the AA12 for Patriarch disposal; 20 rounds delivered as quickly as possible isn't as elegant as a crossbow bolt, but it can be effective. A bit of vulgarity is standard issue in the Support class; after all, it's about shotguns and welders... (Where are the cigars?)