Well i'm not telling nobody nothing about whether er not they should, shouldn't, do, don't, play, toss, their mother's uncle.
Y'all can do what'cha want.
But as everybody has the right to choose, I have the right to express myself, much like everybody else in here, including the ones getting all'riled up over others doing the same as them.
I didn't read all the way through this thread, but I haven't seen too many people "demanding" and/or "threatening" others to not get BF3.
People are expressing themselves and saying why they prefer one over the other. What people have to say might not be all flowers & rainbows up the arse, too bad.
People come in here to say they like something or they say they hate this game, they hate that game. It ain't new.
Why do people compare both games all the time? How does it relate to the forums?
Both games are popular in their own groups, both are trying to rival one another in the online fps area, and people don't have money to blow on crap or games they may not like. Some people can only pick one or the other for a while, or ever.
Myself?
I was burned on BF2 & BFBC2, both I either hated or just lost interest, I will not give a 3rd chance. Same with CoD.
Though if they do something decent with Day of Defeat eventually, that'd be sweet. The mod had so much potential.