so you're saying that community created games are trash? crawl under your rock and learn history, ro1 started as community created content, and twi wasn't always a "group of designers". it's easy to forget and bow to the almighty dollar..until it bites you in the ***, that is.
No. RO1 was made by a group of modders with a fairly shared vision. If the "Community" that is found on the forums was in charge of development, we wouldn't even have a playable game yet, but two dozen piles of unplayable junk, and one or two half way decent mods from splinter groups who gave the rest of the community the finger and went off to do their own thing so they could actually get something accomplished.
Despite what a lot of people seem to think, game design and game development is
hard.
Very hard in fact. That is why it costs millions of dollars, and takes large teams years to produce AAA titles. And even then a lot of them fall flat on their faces.
When you give way to "Community Design", you get tons of idiots who like X, therefore they push for X, because X is 'cool', and therefore "X must be a great design", all the while they give zero thought as to how X actually impacts the rest of the game.