District 9

  • Please make sure you are familiar with the forum rules. You can find them here: https://forums.tripwireinteractive.com/index.php?threads/forum-rules.2334636/

Bluehawk

FNG / Fresh Meat
Feb 13, 2006
2,392
431
0
Hamilton, ON
District 9 had themes of racism (towards the aliens), but to say "OMG it's like the aliens are like black people under apartheid, it's a metaphor, hurr hurr" is pretty stupid, that's obviously not the case.

That was the whole heart and soul of the film.
 

Nestor Makhno

FNG / Fresh Meat
Feb 25, 2006
5,758
1,118
0
56
Penryn, Cornwall
District 9 had themes of racism (towards the aliens), but to say "OMG it's like the aliens are like black people under apartheid, it's a metaphor, hurr hurr" is pretty stupid, that's obviously not the case.

According to the director the film was meant as a pretty direct satire of the way black people were treated under apartheid. In fact the name of the film is even based on an actual black people's squatters camp called District 6 in Jo'burg (I can't find the reference but I remember reading Blomkamp saying that and a SA friend of mine confirming it) from which all the 'squatters' were evicted en massse during apartheid.

*Edit* Ooops - cape town
 
Last edited:

SheepDip

FNG / Fresh Meat
Nov 21, 2005
3,626
495
0
38
The Elitist Prick Club
From IMDB.

All the shacks in District 9 were actual shacks that exists in a section of Johannesburg which were to be evacuated and the residents moved to better government housing, paralleling the events in the film. Also paralleling, the residents had not actually been moved out before filming began. The only shack that was created solely for filming was Christopher Johnson's shack.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_Six,_Cape_Town

See! Interesting!
 
Last edited:

D3terioNation

FNG / Fresh Meat
Dec 15, 2005
3,959
82
0
40
West Sussex, UK
That's art, why can't it be the case? At some level it is the case.

Remember the, ho-hum, was it the... err, the Texas Chainsaw Massacre, the remake from a couple years back?

With all that US flag-waving, the mutants looking like inbred Mexicans on the loose, the protagonists a Johnny Average American family in their pickup and trailer and, super-camp, scene where the uber-mutant is killed with an American flag driven into its body? It just screamed "symbolic of the Latino immigration" to me, the whole movie, start to finish!
Symbolic undertones can perfectly co-exist alongside normal content, it's just another layer of the movie. Not everyone has to see it, not everyone has to agree with it, but it's potentially there for some folks.

Well put!

Yeh the film is extremely deep and wholey relevant to whats going on today as well as during apartheid!

Today in SA, alot of violent crime is committed by desperate people from neighbouring countries. Like the recent killing of a Welsh ex-pat was committed by Mozambicans!!

It angers me that South Africa is seen as being a violent place to visit which costs the country. We lose out on vital revenue for development because of these people. Nigerians are especially to blame as they run all the major cartels in Jo'burg & Durban.

Therefore people dont think twice about being derogative towards these Africans!

South Africans want to move forward but the country's image is being tarnished by these violent foreign criminals!!
 

KrazyKraut

FNG / Fresh Meat
Nov 22, 2005
1,848
69
0
Beer capital of the world
I acknowledge the symbolism and like how it is a different type of alien movie.

But overall I can't help the feeling that more could've been made of this. The second half was all gore and rather average (imo) action. While there's nothing wrong with that per se, had the movie been a little more quiet a little longer it had made a more lasting impression on me.

Still a good movie, 4/5.
 
Last edited:

Reddog

FNG / Fresh Meat
Dec 7, 2005
2,572
476
0
Australia
I acknowledge the symbolism and like how it is a different type of alien movie.

But overall I can't help the feeling that more could've been made of this. The second half was all gore and rather average (imo) action. While there's nothing wrong with that per se, had the movie been a little more quiet a little longer it had made a more lasting impression on me.

Still a good movie, 4/5.
I tend to agree, I liked it to the point where it turned into a mecha-anime.
 

Xendance

FNG / Fresh Meat
Nov 21, 2005
4,484
572
0
32
Elitist Prick Club RS Branch
You strike me as someone who actually enjoyed transformers 2 and G.I. Joe.

Didn't go to watch Transformers 2 and I didn't even know what G.I. Joe was up until a few weeks ago.

I didn't want to watch the main guy constantly blabber something and sweat at the same time. It was all talk and no action, or so I thought first.
 

omarfw

FNG / Fresh Meat
Jun 13, 2009
2,502
85
0
Here Be Dragons
www.last.fm
Didn't go to watch Transformers 2 and I didn't even know what G.I. Joe was up until a few weeks ago.

I didn't want to watch the main guy constantly blabber something and sweat at the same time. It was all talk and no action, or so I thought first.

there's no such thing as a good movie that is all action and no talk.

unless you have a brick for a brain. then I suppose all action and no talk would be just fine.

sure district 9 had a bit too much talking, but would you really care about the 2 main chars at the end if they hadn't had all that character development?
 

D3terioNation

FNG / Fresh Meat
Dec 15, 2005
3,959
82
0
40
West Sussex, UK
I personally think there was PLENTY of action from start to finish!

The end piece would have had to be ridiculously epic & thus destroying all credibility, if there was 'more action' :rolleyes:
 

KrazyKraut

FNG / Fresh Meat
Nov 22, 2005
1,848
69
0
Beer capital of the world
The CNN documentation part was the innovative (if you want to call it that) one wasn't it? I mean a nerdy guy blasting his way through aliens, evil mercs and blacks isn't exactly new :D It's like Half-Life plus Nigerian warlords :p

Anyways, to each his own. This way, at least everyone had his half glass of water and it seems everyone thought the glass was half full and not half empty.;)
 

Pvt.pile

FNG / Fresh Meat
Nov 22, 2005
1,500
206
0
Sconnie Botland
It was based in South Africa, a refreshing change from the USA TBH, so being set in SA the underlying racism would always be a part of anything that comes out of there given its past.