naw he's just clearly never tried to code a game before.
and he's right, graphics aren't what make a game good. anyone who's ever owned an n64 can testify to this.
the video game market having just had a big graphics generation increase with new graphics cards and consoles coming out has been so obsessed with quality of graphics that they aren't bothering to spend time on making their games actually fun. I'm sorry but if you think a game like force unleashed or gears of war are the most awesome games of all time then you have no idea what a fun game is. those games are pure graphical fluff with minimal simplistic gameplay. they are the kind of games you play once and then stick it on your shelf.
there's a reason that many people still play unreal tournament 99 despite the fact that its 10 years old.