Is the force feedback really necessary? I've read a couple of reviews saying the auto center wears out. Any of you guys experience this?
Owning both a FF and a non-FF joystick (same model, BTW, MS Sidewinder Precision Pro) I can assure you that it definately plays differently.
I would say the non-FF one is easier to handle and more precise because you don't experience any gun recoil (apart from the screen shaking), allowing for quite some sniping shots.
It also does auto-center more easily, but I doubt that is due to wear but rather the nonexisting influence of airstream on the flaps and aerlions (which you would experience in a real plane, btw).
Generally, if you want to simulate the planes depicted in Il-2, a FF stick is definately the better choice as a non-FF stick handles just like a fly-by-wire plane which is a modern concept
Because it requires an additional power connection I am using the non-FF stick most of the time (I'm sort of out of power sockets in the hear vicinity of my rig...).
It's also heavier and a bit bigger but that should not be a problem when it's placed on a desk (the non-FF model can actually be held in both hands, it has a sort of gripping handle beneath it - very nice for arcadish sci-fi shooters as it feels more gamepad-like
)
So, no, FF is certainly no necessity, but it's nice to have.
For beginners it may be easier to go without it, but generally comes down to personal preference.
I would strongly advise you to try the model out at the shop if possible.
Oh, and make sure it's connected and a game is loaded up because otherwise it feels a bit "impotent"