Poll on Clipping Through Players

G

Goten

Grizzled Veteran

Sep 1, 2011

432

230

Sep 30, 2011

#21

• Sep 30, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #21

SchabeOink said:

EDITED TO INCLUDE MORE QUOTES



Clipping through enemies isn't confirmed AFAIK and doesn't seem to be a major issue, hence the presumably. I think the reported melee issues people are having stem from a different problem so I didn't want to overcrowd the poll...

I think keep it as it is would suit you for this poll

I can confirm it for you It happens, try with a friend on a empty server.

It affects melee

Click to expand...

 

Upvote 0

Z

Zaltehook

Active member

Sep 4, 2011

37

13

Sep 30, 2011

#22

• Sep 30, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #22

I'd much rather have player collisions, at least on "Hardcore Realism" servers. Clipping through other players just feels so...wrong and kills the immersion.

While I do see the reasoning as to why it works how it does now (griefing of sorts, no blockage on charges, etc.) I feel that the game would benefit from having player models collide, friend and foe alike.

RO1 had it and BF3 has it as well and they both function perfectly fine with it.

 

Upvote 0

K

Korpayne

Member

Sep 19, 2011

7

0

Sep 30, 2011

#23

• Sep 30, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #23

I think if tripwire really want the game to be considered in any way realistic then they need to add it, make it an option that can be turned on or off.

 

Last edited: Sep 30, 2011

Upvote 0

SchabeOink

Grizzled Veteran

Sep 9, 2011

123

23

Sep 30, 2011

#24

• Sep 30, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #24

I can confirm it for you It happens, try with a friend on a empty server.

It affects melee

Click to expand...

That needs to go then specially with the melee problems it causes!

However it seems more like a bug or even unintentional oversight rather then like an intentional feature which the friendly noclip definitly is.

 

Last edited: Sep 30, 2011

Upvote 0

R

Rumpullpus

Grizzled Veteran

Aug 31, 2011

329

70

Sep 30, 2011

#25

• Sep 30, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #25

actually was one of the few things i really hated in RO1 one dumbass would block a door out of the spawn and everyone couldnt get around him.

im glad i can move through people.

 

Upvote 0

Nikita

Grizzled Veteran

May 5, 2011

1,874

606

Sep 30, 2011

#26

• Sep 30, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #26

Just tested this in a server as a German with a Russian. There is no clipping through enemies. If you think you walked through someone while trying to stab them, you just walked past them.

I repeat, there is NO clipping through enemies.

:IS2:

 

Upvote 0

SchabeOink

Grizzled Veteran

Sep 9, 2011

123

23

Sep 30, 2011

#27

• Sep 30, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #27

Nikita said:

Just tested this in a server as a German with a Russian. There is no clipping through enemies.

Click to expand...

The way I see this thread:
-Friendly Noclip is a feature and we find out wether we like it or not
-Possible Enemy Noclip is an atrocity that should not exist under any circumstances

 

Upvote 0

K

knigtstemplar

Grizzled Veteran

Feb 18, 2006

89

15

Location, Location

www.xtremeassault.com

Oct 1, 2011

#28

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #28

Don't block doorways and passage ways. Clipping has to stay.

 

Upvote 0

A

Arete

Grizzled Veteran

Nov 26, 2005

329

10

Sweden

www.aretemusic.tk

Oct 1, 2011

#29

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #29

I vote for option 1, but would like..

option 4 - Clipping enable for your own team, no clipping with the enemy.

This would stop any griefing with blocking doorways and such, while making CQB/melee feel more natural. It's horrible when you bayo charge someone in a dark place and they go right through you before you notice them.

 

Upvote 0

angelangel

Grizzled Veteran

May 31, 2006

489

22

30

Singapore

Oct 1, 2011

#30

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #30

There should be clipping through TEAM MATES but not through the enemy!

 

Upvote 0

B

Baine

Grizzled Veteran

Aug 2, 2006

196

39

Oct 1, 2011

#31

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #31

You need another option, because teammate clipping might be "meh", but i see that it is needed. Enemy clipping on the other hand is really bad, and results in some really bad situations.

So make a new option as the guy above said with "No enemy clipping".

 

Upvote 0

T

The_Cook

Grizzled Veteran

May 10, 2006

542

177

Oct 1, 2011

#32

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #32

I vote for no character clipping for anyone. but this might be a serverside cpu use issue. idk.

Be an asshat and block a doorway get shot in the back of the head.

 

Upvote 0

MadTommy

Grizzled Veteran

Oct 13, 2008

301

143

Oct 1, 2011

#33

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #33

Please keep it as it is.. there is nothing more annoying than players blocking doors & windows. Gameplay before realism on this one for me.

 

Upvote 0

F

>< f4ct0r...13

Grizzled Veteran

Sep 2, 2011

379

215

California

Oct 1, 2011

#34

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #34

What a shame to see player clipping.

 

Upvote 0

Das Bose

Grizzled Veteran

May 8, 2009

1,572

867

Sunny Scarborough

Oct 1, 2011

#35

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #35

I couldn't care less either way. However if I had to pick one I would go for the way it is now. Annoying players are far better as open windows than locked doors.

 

Upvote 0

Nikita

Grizzled Veteran

May 5, 2011

1,874

606

Oct 1, 2011

#36

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #36

Sorry to repeat myself, but there is no clipping through the enemy!

 

Upvote 0

E

EvilKiwi436

Grizzled Veteran

Aug 26, 2011

119

98

Oct 1, 2011

#37

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #37

Guys, clipping is great. Not through enemies, but through allies for sure. I was just playing the BF3 beta, and I was constantly pushed into the line of fire by ifiot teammates, annoys me to no end.

 

Upvote 0

R

realninja

Grizzled Veteran

Oct 31, 2010

274

64

Oct 1, 2011

#38

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #38

just add griefing as a votekick option

 

Upvote 0

Hilldog

Grizzled Veteran

Sep 3, 2011

84

10

Oct 1, 2011

#39

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #39

I voted to keep it as it is, I personally just don't mind the clipping, I've yet to be in a situation where it's bothered me.

 

Upvote 0

D

DrownedOut

FNG / Fresh Meat

Sep 24, 2011

3

1

Oct 1, 2011

#40

• Oct 1, 2011

• Add bookmark
• #40

I think as long as you are not playing on a 64 player apartments server this is a non-issue.

 

Upvote 0