They were accurate enough for me. Matter of taste, I guess. The recoil in Freedom Fighters felt great though, don't you think?
Definately a cool game. Great environments, awesome setting, chilling soundtrack and a fun game to go with it. Also a fine attention to detail. Like your character's appearance changes throughout the game.
I only have to real relatively minor gripes with it, the rest is really minor stuff:
The first is the obvious betrayel plot-line but it wasn't bad enough to damage the setting and the rest of the story, and the second is that on the xbox aiming is done by clicking and holding the LEFT analogue stick! That's unusual and for at least pretty uncomfortable and it's not possible to change it in the options. There isn't even an option to make it toggle!
9/10 imo.